We told you about our neighborhood fake Cupcake last week. She’s still around, and she tried to follow a visitor into the house a few days ago! But Misty isn’t the only fake Cupcake going around.
Cupcake’s foster mom has a cat who is also a fake Cupcake.
Kitten Cupcake (then named Dior):
And fake kitten Cupcake:
Real kitten Cupcake:
Fake Cupcake:
Fake kitten Cupcake is named Gargoyle, in honor of real Cupcake’s habit of lurking on top of the bathroom cabinet like a gargoyle.
Little Gargoyle is full of sass, just like her namesake. If you ever wanted your own Cupcake, Gargoyle will be available for adoption soon from Colony Cats in Ohio.
UPDATE: Gargoyle was adopted!

Both adorable!!!!!
Oh my, there is really a resemblance!
They really do look alike!
Dang, you’re really famous Cupcake, the fakes are showing up everywhere!
Oh my! You two must be related somehow!
the darling.
They could be twins!
Alime right to the spot on their back and the attitude. 🙂
You’re so famous everyone wants to be you, Cupcake!
Love that lil Gargoyle! Cupcake too, of course 🥰
So many Cupcakes! All so cute!!
This is beginning to get confusing! 😺
Cupcake, you have so many dopplegangers!
There is allus only ONE TRUE CUPCAKE!
I think this is one instance where having a fake is a good thing.
Yay for Gargoyle! Cupcake must be one of the cool cats to have so many imitators!